Letters to the Bishops of Africa on Caelestius and Pelagius (417)
Two letters of Zosimus of Rome to Aurelius of Carthage and the bishops of Africa, written in 417 after he had heard Caelestius and read Pelagius’s statement of faith. They are his own account of what he did, before he condemned both men in 418.
Read the text at archive.org ↗The second letter, Postquam a nobis (pp. 103–108) ↗
Both letters are addressed to Aurelius of Carthage and all the bishops of Africa and are preserved in the collection of imperial and papal letters known as the Collectio Avellana. The text is damaged in places, and the editor marks several passages as corrupt.
The first, Magnum pondus (no. 45), reports the hearing of Caelestius in the basilica of St Clement at Rome. Its date line keeps the consuls of 417, Honorius for the eleventh time and Constantius, but the day has dropped out. The second, Postquam a nobis (no. 46), reports the public reading of a letter and statement of faith sent by Pelagius and is dated the eleventh day before the Kalends of October, 21 September, with no year; the editor assigns it to 417. The collection heads the first letter as written “in defence of Caelestius against the African bishops”; that heading is the compiler’s and not part of the letter.
These are the words of the bishop who judged the case, written while it was open. Augustine of Hippo’s account of the same hearing, in On the Grace of Christ and on Original Sin, was written the next year, after Zosimus had condemned both men.
Cited in
- AD 411 to AD 418, estimated date