The Third Council of Constantinople
AD 680 to AD 681, firm dateFirm date
A council called by the emperor Constantine IV defines that Christ has two wills and two operations, divine and human, never opposed. It condemns the teaching of one will and those who had upheld it, among them four patriarchs of Constantinople and Pope Honorius.
The Council of Chalcedon had taught that Christ is one person in two natures. In the seventh century a further question divided the churches of the empire: whether Christ had one will and one “operation”, or two. At the opening session the Roman legates said that for some forty-six years bishops of Constantinople, Sergius, Pyrrhus, Paul and Peter, with Cyrus of Alexandria, had taught one will and one operation; their opponents answered that they had this teaching from the councils and the fathers, from those same bishops, and from Honorius, a former pope of Rome (Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 1).
The teaching had been resisted before. Theophanes relates that the monk Maximus debated the deposed patriarch Pyrrhus in Africa and then went to Rome, where he urged Pope Martin to hold a synod; it affirmed two wills in Christ. The emperor Constans II had Martin and Maximus brought to Constantinople and exiled, and had Maximus’s tongue cut out and his hand cut off (Theophanes, Chronicle AM 6121 (pp. 331–332)) (Theophanes, Chronicle AM 6160 (pp. 351–352)).
Constans’s son Constantine IV changed course and asked Rome to send delegates (Theophanes, Chronicle AM 6160 (pp. 351–352)) (Theophanes, Chronicle AM 6171–6172 (pp. 359–360)) (Liber Pontificalis Agatho (ed. Duchesne, vol. 1, pp. 350–354)). Pope Agatho sent bishops, priests and monks with two letters, his own and one from a Roman synod of 125 bishops (Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 1) (Liber Pontificalis Agatho (ed. Duchesne, vol. 1, pp. 350–354)). His letter sets out the doctrine of “two natural wills, and two natural operations” and claims that the Roman church “has never erred from the path of the apostolic tradition” (Council of Constantinople (680–681), letter of Agatho). A letter of the emperor to George, patriarch of Constantinople, dated 10 September in its Latin version, says that the envoys have now come to him and handed over the two letters, and tells George to summon his metropolitans and bishops to the capital (Council of Constantinople (680–681), letter of Constantine IV to George of Constantinople (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 201–204)). The Liber Pontificalis dates the legates’ entry into the city to 10 November and their reception in the Trullus to 22 November (Liber Pontificalis Agatho (ed. Duchesne, vol. 1, pp. 350–354)). The minutes date the first session to 7 November 680, in the hall of the palace called the Trullus, with the emperor presiding (Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 1, heading (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 209–210)). Macarius, patriarch of Antioch, who would not give up the doctrine of one will, was deposed (Liber Pontificalis Agatho (ed. Duchesne, vol. 1, pp. 350–354)).
At its thirteenth session the council condemned Sergius, Cyrus, Pyrrhus, Paul, Peter and Theodore of Pharan, and with them Honorius, “because of what we found written by him to Sergius, that in all respects he followed his view” (Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 13). Its definition repeats the faith of Chalcedon and adds that there are in Christ
two natural wills and two natural operations indivisibly, inconvertibly, inseparably, inconfusedly.
The human will is not opposed to the divine but follows it, as in the saying “not to do my own will, but the will of him who sent me” (John 6:38) (Council of Constantinople (680–681), definition of faith). The bishops told the emperor that “Peter spoke through Agatho”, and addressed the pope as bishop of “the first see of the Universal Church” (Council of Constantinople (680–681), address to the emperor) (Council of Constantinople (680–681), letter to Agatho).
Theophanes counts 289 bishops and calls this the sixth ecumenical council (Theophanes, Chronicle AM 6171–6172 (pp. 359–360)). Both the Greek East and the Latin West received it as such: a council at Constantinople in 692 confirmed its faith (Council in Trullo canon 1), and the Catholic Church cites it under the same title (Catechism of the Catholic Church 475).
How this is dated
Firm date. Fixed by contemporary documentation and not seriously disputed.
The minutes head the first session with the seventh day of November in the ninth indiction and the twenty-seventh year of Constantine IV (Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 1, heading (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 209–210)). The ninth indiction ran from September 680 to August 681, so the day is 7 November 680.
The Liber Pontificalis, written at Rome, has the legates enter Constantinople on 10 November of the ninth indiction and places their reception in the Trullus on 22 November (Liber Pontificalis Agatho (ed. Duchesne, vol. 1, pp. 350–354)). Neither date agrees with the council’s own documents: the emperor’s letter of 10 September already reports that the legates have come (Council of Constantinople (680–681), letter of Constantine IV to George of Constantinople (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 201–204)), and the minutes open on 7 November (Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 1, heading (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 209–210)). Louis Duchesne set this out in the notes to his edition (Le Liber pontificalis, vol. 1, 1886, p. 356, notes 14 and 16): the arrival cannot be later than 10 September 680, and the Roman writer gathers under 22 November what the minutes spread over sessions held from 7 November 680 to March 681. The timeline follows the acts.
In the text cited, the date of the emperor’s letter stands in the heading of the Latin version only, and its regnal figures, the twenty-eighth year and the twelfth after the consulship, differ from the twenty-seventh and thirteenth in the heading of the first session (Council of Constantinople (680–681), letter of Constantine IV to George of Constantinople (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 201–204)) (Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 1, heading (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 209–210)).
Primary sources
Scripture
Acts of the Third Council of Constantinople
- Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 1ccel.org
- Council of Constantinople (680–681), letter of Agathoccel.org
- Council of Constantinople (680–681), letter of Constantine IV to George of Constantinople (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 201–204)archive.org
- Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 1, heading (Mansi, vol. 11, cols 209–210)archive.org
- Council of Constantinople (680–681), session 13ccel.org
- Council of Constantinople (680–681), definition of faithccel.org
- Council of Constantinople (680–681), address to the emperorccel.org
- Council of Constantinople (680–681), letter to Agathoccel.org
In context
Grows out of
- AD 553, firm date
Leads to
- AD 787, firm date