He gave them bread out of heaven to eat
In John the crowd that had been fed asks Jesus for a sign and quotes Scripture to him: their fathers ate the manna in the wilderness, as it is written. Jesus answers that it was not Moses who gave the bread from heaven. John does not say where the words are written.
The words quoted
He rained down manna on them to eat, and gave them food from the sky.
Behold, I will rain bread from the sky for you …
Where they are quoted
Our fathers ate the manna in the wilderness. As it is written, ‘He gave them bread out of heaven to eat.’
The two passages compared
In John, on the day after the feeding, the crowd comes to Capernaum looking for Jesus. He tells them to work for the food that remains to eternal life and to believe in him whom God has sent. They ask what sign he does, that they may see and believe: “Our fathers ate the manna in the wilderness. As it is written, ‘He gave them bread out of heaven to eat.’” (John 6:22–31) Here it is the crowd that quotes Scripture, in asking for a sign.
Jesus answers the quotation. It was not Moses who gave the bread out of heaven; his Father gives the true bread out of heaven; and “I am the bread of life” (John 6:32–35).
John does not say where the words are written (John 6:31). In Exodus the Lord says that he will rain bread from heaven, and Moses tells the people that the manna is the bread the Lord has given them to eat (Exodus 16:4, 15). Psalm 78 retells it: the people did not believe, and yet God rained down manna on them to eat and gave them food from the sky, or the “grain of heaven”, as the New Revised Standard Version Updated Edition has it (Psalm 78:22–24). In the ancient Greek translation of the psalm he “gave them the bread of heaven” (Septuagint Psalm 77:24 (78:24 in English Bibles)). A prayer in Nehemiah says of the same years that God gave bread from heaven for the people’s hunger (Nehemiah 9:15).
Primary sources
In the timeline
They are quoted in
- c. AD 29 or 32, estimated dateThe Feeding of the Five Thousand
By the Sea of Galilee, all four Gospels relate, Jesus feeds a crowd of about five thousand with five loaves and two fish. John adds that the crowd wanted to make him king, and the discourse on the bread of life.